Home > Multimedia > Podcast

Podcast Episode 16 | 11 min

The Cutting Room Floor

Preachers need to be more like filmmakers when crafting their sermons.

Available on:

Average Rating:  [see ratings/reviews]The Cutting Room Floor

Matt Woodley: Thanks for joining us on another episode of Monday Morning Preacher. I’m Matt Woodley, editor of PreachingToday.com, and a 25-year journeyman of the fascinating craft of preaching. I’m here with my guest host today, fellow preacher extraordinaire, Kevin Miller.

Kevin Miller: Wow, I love the extraordinaire. It even had like an accent, like a little French flair or something.

MW: You are extraordinaire.

KM: Thank you.

MW: So Kevin, back in 1975, I was 16 years old. There was a blockbuster movie that came out that summer. It was the highest grossing film until the first Star Wars film hit. Any idea what it was?

KM: I don’t know. Airplane?

MW: Wrong. Let me give you a few clues.

KM: Thanks for letting me down gently.

MW: Summer. At the beach. Scary. Blood. Then this. [Jaws theme song] Yeah, Jaws, the thriller produced by Steven Spielberg about the giant man-eating great white shark that attacked folks at the New England summer resort town. Well, most people didn’t know that this movie was actually based on a novel, and the novel had all kinds of plots and subplots and twists and turns, so Spielberg had to do a lot of cutting from the book and then once the movie was finished he had all the scenes, he had to do a lot of cutting of the scenes. For instance, there’s this one really weird scene that got cut. The main character, a guy named Quint, he goes to the hardware store to buy some piano wire. While he’s in there, there’s this kid who’s playing the clarinet in the hardware store. Seriously.

KM: That’s weird.

MW: And Quint kind of goes crazy and he starts bopping along with the song, and he gets so loud he drowns the kid out, freaks the kid out, etc., etc., and it got cut.

KM: So I’m guessing that somewhere in this interminably long introduction of yours there is a theme for today’s podcast.

MW: There’s a theme. So here’s what we’re going to talk about today: The preacher’s cutting room floor.

KM: Oh, great topic.

MW: There will be scenes that you want to leave out of your sermon. Stuff, lots of stuff, that you will need to cut and leave on the cutting room floor. So Kevin, why is this so hard for preachers?

KM: Well, speaking for myself, when I’ve done my homework, exegesis, and I’ve thought about something, prayed about something and I get a great insight, I feel very attached to it. It’s almost like connected to me. It doesn’t feel like my work, like I’m holding it out at arm’s length. It feels like it’s inside me now. So the thought of cutting that out is kind of painful.

MW: Sure, I think every preacher can relate to that. There is a journalist named Roy Peter Clark who put it this way. He said, “When writers fall in love with their words, it is a good feeling that can lead to a bad effect.” Exactly what you’re talking about, right? When we fall in love with our words, Clark says, our quotes, our characters, our anecdotes – think of all our biblical exegesis, etc. – we cannot kill any of them. But then he says, “But kill them we must.” Ouch. So here’s my first bit of advice for preachers: Get used to it. Get used to the cutting room floor.

No First PageNo Previous PagePage 1 of 4

H.B. Charles is the Pastor-Teacher at the Shiloh Metropolitan Baptist Church in Jacksonville, Florida.

H.B. Charles:

Rating & Reviews

Average User Rating:

Displaying 1–1 of 1 comments

David Benedict

June 05, 2017  4:55pm

Good program. I'm retired and rarely preach anymore, but I used to teach preaching to ministerial students, and appreciate the ideas shared and the enthusiasm in presenting them. I wanted to say you could have used examples of how exegetical points are overused in messages-- but of course you left those on the cutting room floor in favor of your main ideas. I also thought from the title that we'd here something more about putting biblical stories and events into dramatic narrative scenes-- but that was that other sermon that didn't need to be preached this Monday morning. Thanks for the stimulating thought and the soundbite from H. B. Chalrles.

Report Abuse

Review and Rate this Article: *



1000 character limit

* Comments may be edited for tone and clarity.

Related Sermon Illustrations

Quickly Versus Deeply

Larry McMurtry, known for his [book] Lonesome Dove, wrote another book about roads—the many roads he had driven on and the hundreds of miles he had explored across America. At ...

[ Read More ]

Medical Student Learns Valuable Lesson

In his book Better: A Surgeon's Notes on Performance, Atul Gawande recalls a patient he encountered during his final year of medical school. The older woman's complaint was simple ...

[ Read More ]

More Sermon illustrations

Related videos

Stuff | Floodgate Productions | Preaching Today Media

Stuff | Floodgate Productions

We all carry stuff - some good, some not so good. And when we come to church, it’s easy to leave our stuff in the parking lot, then walk into the church building with a smile, as if our stuff doesn’t really exist. But what if the invitation from Christ is something different, and what if your church can communicate that invitation with clarity and inspiration? [ Read More ]
Keyhole Nebula | Playback Media | Preaching Today Media

Keyhole Nebula | Playback Media

The name of this image is actually NGC 3324 and a few other lame names, but we liked this name the best. Taken by the Hubble Space Satellite a few years ago, now available in stunning clarity and movement. [ Read More ]

More videos

Print this pageShopping CartHelpMy Account